It doesn't matter if he fired first. He's defending his planet from a hostile fleet. And you fail to see the pointlessness of your arguing that he must RP it out.

Its RPing a tactic that stated in Canon that took hours to complete in minutes, and yes a hostile fleet that powered down its weapons.

*shakes his head* Forget it. YOu don't understand.

I understand what you are trying to say, and I'm saying its a form of godmoding to just assume you can do it.

Kraken:
About the above where Marth was ignoring your post.

1.You don't have any ships in the system, so you can't cause damage to him.

So legally, he can ignore you damages.

Not really. Most people don't RP out how they're going to do their defenses.

I didn't do any damages to his ships. He did them himself, and I am merely posting up the damages, since he so conviently ignored doing it himself.

Anyways, this thread and the corresponding one in Battlegrounds should go down in history in TRF. Don't know what we should advertise it as, but no something good, that's damn sure.

RPing a simple defense yes, RPing possibly one of the greastest tactical feats ever imagined by Zhan and used by Thrawn, no.

*shrug* I didn't do it. Ask him about it. And Kraken, show some curtsey to the person that started the thread and wait for them to post before you post again.

It be along the lines of say using an ISD's gravimetric sensors to detect a cloaked shroud.