Thought this would be interesting to see what every one's options ended up being...

Mine is Gnomeo and Juliet Vs Murder She Wrote...

Jessica Fletcher would so win this one

The 1991 Sherlock Holmes with Christopher Lee

vs

Top Gear (the original British one)

That would be... an interesting fight.

True Grit vs Hell On Wheels.

I think I must have gotten stuck in a genre.

Wrong Turn 4 vs The Daily Show with Jon Stewart

Oh my. Will those inbred imps be able to stomach him?

I don't know, I think Stewart would fight dirty, he is a celeb

Tom Hanks from Cast Away vs. uhh... Oh, The Doctor and crew.

They wouldn't really fight they would just have crazy adventures?

Bone Eater (2007) vs the Wrestlers from WWE Smackdown.

Mine would be Joe and Old Joe (Looper) against Sherlock Holmes (Elementary).

Batman Begins Bruce Wayne vs. Michael Westen and Crew from Burn Notice... this would be an interesting fight. Too close for me to call.

that would be a tough one to call...