The X-Wing has a better wepon system,but the tie is more agile

Comparing one to another requires degree.

The X-wing compared to the original Hex-winged TIE/ln fighter is superior every time.

X-wing compared to TIE Interceptor - 50-50. The Interceptor has four lasers and incredible speeds, allowing it to dogfight with the Xwing provided it is not hit.

TIE-Defender compared to X-wing - Defender wins all the time.

I'd go with the X-Wing. Put a TIE in atmosphere and it's useless. Plus, the original TIES aren't even hyperspace capable.

I know that - since I had to answer the question separately. The TIE/ln is a miserable craft who's only ability is speed and given the circumstances is more detriment than aide.

I like the Tie-interseptor above the Xwing.

i think i speak for everyone when i say...

WTF.

O this is mij toy

either your a super-stoner since your from amsterdam...

or...

your another live one...

I think that the Interceptors and Defenders count as different ships than the one specified by the question. If the question is A New Hope TIE v.s. A New Hope X-wing, tthen it is up to debate. 1 on 1, X wing wins every time. In a battle situation, X-wings have a big advantage, but for different kinds of missions like hit-and-run, or defensive battles, it all depends on the circumstance. But the X wing is better because it doesn't have to rely as much on capital ships.

X-Wing.

But then, it depends on the pilot, too... but I'd say the X-Wing has the over all advantage in any given situation.